Three episodes in and the new BBC sitcom Citizen Khan is sort of improving. Yesterday night’s episode had a throwaway line at the start where Mr Khan got annoyed at being phoned up by a call centre operative from Mumbai – a deft 21st century touch that there are too few of. Whereas “The Kumars at 42″ and “Bend It Like Beckham” recognised the suburbanisation of Asians this grim oop north sub-Hovis ad seems stuck in a 70s groove harking back to the decade that time forgot in interior decor and sophistication of humour. Once again there were loads of tweets flooding in starkly divided between lols and cringes. My longer take on the programme went up over the weekend at Huffington Post and can be read here.
Here is Ali from “Mind Your Language” by way of a memory jog:
In answer to the comments:
Some of the posters have the right idea but others are comically outraged at my original thoughts – disgusted on Tonbridge Wells lives online. One looks like they have just discovered inverted commas so determined to use them every other word, a bit like my eight year old. Funniest one was someone who said the best thing about it was that it reminded them to renew their EDL membership. Cannot find it now, possibly removed by moderator.
Another declared “As professor of sociology the write [sic] should know better than to dismiss a milestone in the depiction of Islam in the mainstream media”. Thanks for elevating but am several paygrades below this rank I’m afraid.
Further reading: Huq, R. (1996) on all this and “the burden of representation” in the classic text “Disorienting Rhythms” available for download here.


4 comments
Comments feed for this article
September 12, 2012 at 12:48 am
monty
Just watched a few clips on youtube… Citizen Cringeworthy. For all its many, many flaws at least ‘It Ain’t Half Hot Mum’ was reasonably amusing.
October 18, 2012 at 5:57 pm
Robin Taylor
Most of my Pakistani friends think it is hilarious, and some of them equate Mr Khan to people they know within their community. On the other hand, one white English (Labour Party) friend regards it as racist. I’m not sure that criticism can really be directed at the programme makers given that some of them are themselves drawn from the Asian community, although one potential problem may be that most of the characters are played by people with Hindu names. I’m not sure it’s an astute observation to make but in one sense it may, in the eyes of the wider audience, serve to humanise a religion whose adherents have been so often demonised.
October 18, 2012 at 5:58 pm
Robin Taylor
By the way, I couldn’t get your Huffington Post link to work.
October 21, 2012 at 9:31 pm
rupahuq
Oops sorry Robin, thanks for your comments, have fixed that link. Here it is again:
http://www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/dr-rupa-huq/citizen-khan-asians-on-the-box_b_1856948.html?utm_hp_ref=tw
Am doing a longer academic article on the subject too as part of a “Citizen Khan” special. Will keep you (and everyone else on this) blog posted.